When an over-reliance on human controls led to serious injury
What happened?
A 14 year old boy was sitting alongside an adult at a garage awaiting the completion of an MOT. The chair he was sitting on was positioned right in front of the brake rollers. As the MOT technician attempted to reverse the car, it unexpectedly surged forward off the brake rollers, pinning the child against the wall.
The teenager required urgent medical attention after sustaining multiple fractures in his pelvis. He was unable to attend school for more than a year and spent three months bedridden as a result of the incident.
The MOT Centre featured a designated ‘viewing area’ adjacent to the brake roller bay. This space was marked by a painted box on the floor, complete with a chair situated inside it. There were, however, no safety barriers in place, and the business did not prevent customers from stepping out of this area into parts of the workshop where vehicles were in motion.
Legal Outcome
The MOT centre admitted breaching section 3(1) of the Health and Safety at Work Act due to its negligence in ensuring the health, safety, and welfare of individuals not employed by them, and were fined £10,000 plus costs of £6,810.
What can we learn from what happened?
As will have been stated a few times in this case study library, workplace transport is the second biggest cause of fatalities in the workplace in the UK. Whenever space is shared between a something with wheels that moves and a person, and that person is hit by said vehicle, then the person will always come off badly.
And this is what happened. The car will not have been travelling at any kind of speed when it lurched off the brake rollers, but its speed coupled with the crushing of the boy against the wall was enough to cause serious injury.
This accident was clearly very easy to avoid. There were at least some measures in place to try to keep people away from the cars; that control was, however, entirely dependent on human compliance (less likely with children), whereas a barrier would have provided something more physical and reliable. Then there was the custom and practice of the garage not enforcing their own segregation rules – another human control. And then there was the reliance on the mechanic engaging the reverse gear correctly – another human control.
Lots of reliance on people doing the right thing, and when we rely on people doing the right thing, sometimes they don’t. Best thing is to keep people away from moving workplace transport in a way that doesn’t give them any choice.
Source of Information
IOSH Magazine