5 year-old suffers horrific injury due to exposed rod on a toy football table

When the likelihood of this injury happening was extremely low, but foreseeable nevertheless

What happened? 

A 5 year-old boy was attending a nursery which had a toy football table for the children to play with.

The table toppled over on top of the boy and one of the exposed rods punctured his left eye and went through to his brain.  Three years after the accident, the boy still needed significant medical support.

The investigation revealed that football table had been reported as being defective because a handle cover had come off prior to the accident, but it had ‘not been logged or reported’  The prosecutor said: “If this had been logged, action may have been taken.”

Legal Outcome

The nursery’s company directors pleaded guilty to failing to promptly report the accident.  They also admitted failing to make a suitable risk assessment.

The Crown Court fined them £20,000, with costs of £2,354.

What can we learn from what happened?

In a play or even educational setting, there will be hazards that would not necessarily present risks to adults, but do so to young children.

The choice of what toys, or any kind of implement or furniture, are in a nursery needs to be very carefully made, and the person making those decisions needs to have a keen eye for potential danger (and without making too much of a generalisation, parents of young children will probably have a keener eye than most).

Constant assessment of the toys etc needs to be made to ensure they remain safe, and if any defect should arise where there is any risk of harm being caused, then it must be rectified immediately or removed from the setting and put out of use.

Also, the foreseeability needs to assessed.  How likely was it that the football table would topple over, how likely was it that the rod would hit the child, how likely was it that it would strike his eye, and how likely was it that it would cause such a serious injury.  The likelihoods decrease as you go through the questions, but it was reasonably foreseeable nevertheless.  And so easy to prevent.

Source of Information

QLM Newsletter

BBC Online

Share this Story

Facebook
Twitter
LinkedIn