8 year old non-swimmer accesses unsupervised pool and drowns

When safety management isn’t about relying on luck

What happened? 

A party of twenty-eight children from a London play scheme on a council estate were attending a scout camp which included a 20m swimming pool with a depth of 1.5m.

A member of staff, aged 21, was responsible for lifeguarding the pool when being used, and also to lock up when all sessions had finished.

At the end of the session, he left the pool to check at the camp office if there was anyone else booked to use it.  He locked the poolside door to the female changing rooms, but failed to lock the boys’ changing room, leaving the pool accessible from outside and unsupervised.

He returned with a fellow lifeguard and noticed trainers, socks, a T-shirt and tracksuit bottoms in the changing rooms.  He said: “I had not been away more than five or ten minutes. It did not occur to me that someone might be swimming unsupervised. I saw the clothes and I expected to find someone swimming.

I walked round the pool and my colleague walked round the other side. I could see a shadow in the water. We realised we had a small body face down in the pool.  I dived in, brought the boy to the surface, took him to the side and starting doing what I was trained to do.”

The boy was 8 years old, and according to his father could not swim and was terrified of water. He was flown to hospital after the incident but died later that day.  It was his first day at the camp, and had not taken part in the organised swimming session earlier in the day. It was his first time away from his parents.

The jury at the inquest was also told that an emergency alarm did not work when his body was discovered.

Legal Outcome

The County Scout Council responsible was fined £15,000 and ordered to pay £10,995 court costs by magistrates after pleading guilty to contravening the Health and Safety at Work Act.

What can we learn from what happened?

Was it bad luck that during the five to ten minutes when the pool was unsupervised, it was accessed by an 8 year old non-swimmer, terrified of water?  Yes, but safety management is about eliminating the need to rely on luck.  It would actually have been ‘lucky’ for the lifeguard to return to the pool to find nobody had drowned.

Luck doesn’t come into it.  In this case study, the lifeguard had control over when the pool was supervised, and while the odds were massive against someone dying, those odds should never be relied on.

This was the second time this scout council had been prosecuted following the death of 16 year-old girl who died after falling under the wheels of a tractor two years earlier at the same camp – see the case study included in this month’s selection.

Source of Information

District Council Report

BBC News Online

The Free Library

Share this Story

Facebook
Twitter
LinkedIn