Man with epilepsy dies falling from a stairway at a major supermarket

When a vulnerable person is not treated as an individual and is at greater risk as a result

What happened? 

The man, who suffered from an epileptic condition, fell from a shop stairway.  The fall caused severe head injuries and he sadly died in hospital two weeks later.

He is believed to have had a seizure when he fell.

The supermarket was aware of the man’s epileptic condition, because he had suffered many previous seizures at work. The man had to walk up the stairs many times each day to collect something from his locker, and to access the staff canteen.

Legal Outcome

The supermarket was charged with three health and safety violations which it denied:

Failure to ensure the health and safety of an employee who had epilepsy.  Failure to carry out a suitable and sufficient assessment of the risks to the employee who had epilepsy.  And failure to review risks to which an employee with epilepsy might be exposed

The supermarket admitted a fourth charge of failing to supply the council with requested information relating to the death of the employee.

The supermarket was found guilty on all four charges.  The judge said that ‘in failing to move the man’s locker downstairs, it failed to treat him as an individual and make appropriate changes’.

The judge placed the offences in the highest category of culpability and harm, and the supermarket was fined £3.5 million.

What can we learn from what happened?

Many organisations employ a lot of people.  For many the risks these staff are exposed to will be similar or the same, but everyone is different, and sometimes what makes us different makes a material difference to those risks.

In this case the man had epilepsy, and this was well known by his employers.  He had suffered previous seizures, so the risks associated with using the stairs, and therefore the potential to fall down the stairs, should have been taken into account.  These risks were specific to this one employee, and the judge recognised that, but it is for the employer to tailor their controls on an individual basis as much as is necessary, and in this case the moving of the locker would have made a real difference.

This doesn’t mean that every individual member of staff will always need to be individually risk assessed, but it will mean that when characteristics, or disabilities, or vulnerabilities mean that an individual is at particular risk, then they need to be treated, like the judge said, as an individual.

Source of Information

SHP In-Court

Share this Story

Facebook
Twitter
LinkedIn