When, even after the fatality, the site manager said the worker was to blame for his own death
What happened?
A man was working on a building site when he fell three metres through a skylight aperture in a first floor roof and sustained serious head injuries.
He was taken to hospital where he subsequently died.
The HSE immediately issued a prohibition notice on the building site manager, ordering a halt to any work at height, but on two subsequent visits, by the HSE and then the police, after the death, they found evidence that work had continued.
The site manager was arrested and charged with manslaughter by gross negligence.
HSE investigations revealed the following:
There was no scaffolding provided in the area where the windows were to be fitted; there was no safe method of transferring the windows to the first floor, where access was only by way of a broken, untethered ladder; ladders were not secured properly and one was found balancing in a pile of sand; nobody on site was wearing any personal protective equipment; there was no qualified first aider on site; openings in the ceilings on the first and second floors were not guarded; there were no signs warning of hazards; and scaffolding was not properly secured on the site.
Legal Outcome
The site manager was found guilty of manslaughter by gross negligence after a trial at Crown Court. He also pleaded guilty to three health and safety offences.
He was sentenced to two and a half years in prison for manslaughter by gross negligence and eight months in prison for the health and safety offences, to run concurrently.
The site manager said in court: ‘If the deceased needed help he should have asked for it and, since he chose to work alone, the deceased only had himself to blame for his misfortune. As far as he was concerned, the site was safe.’
The prosecuting barrister said that even after the fatal fall, the site manager refused to accept any responsibility for the safety of workers on his site.
What can we learn from what happened?
Not withstanding the long list of safety failures identifies in the investigation, what we can learn from this terrible case is that there are still people out there who really think that when someone dies or gets hurt at work it is their fault.
When teaching, I thankfully don’t some across this mentality much, and it is probably becoming less common, but it does happen. It makes teaching health and safety that much more difficult, but more importantly it is a state of mind that puts innocent people at risk of injury, and in this case, at risk of losing their life.
Another point to make is that this is an example of falling through a fragile roof – a very common cause of falling from height, and is a risk that is harder to identify by the person working, so needs very robust controls.
Source of Information
SHP In-Court