16 year old girl crushed by tractor driven by inexperienced scout leader

When, given the muddy conditions, the level of experience and training wasn’t sufficient to control a vehicle weighing tons

What happened? 

A 16 year-old girl was acting as a leader at a scout camp.  She was standing on the footplate of a tractor while it was being driven by a 22 year-old scout leader.  There were two other boys, aged 14 and 15, with her on the footplate.

The scout leader had received no more than twenty-five minutes* instruction on how to operate the vehicle before attempting to drive it over a muddy country path with a three-ton trailer in tow (*in another report it was stated that a site warden had given an inexperienced scout leader a ‘wholly inadequate’ 10 minute driving lesson on the tractor).

The scout leader had been left alone with the tractor after being shown how to use it by one of the camp’s full-time staff.  The forest track was slippery from recent rainfall and when the wheels locked, she fought to remain in control.

The 16 year-old girl fell off the footplate and was run over by the rear wheel of the tractor, causing immediate death from a skull fracture.

She had been a dedicated member of the Venture Scouts and had recently been awarded the Chief Scout Award, one of the movement’s highest achievements.

At the court case, in the Scout Council’s defence it was said that ‘scouts were trained to be independent and act responsibly.  At this scout camp there has never been a serious accident or a fatality.  The choice of scout leader to drive was the right choice. She was legally entitled to drive the tractor on any public road.’

The court was told how the scouts had spent more than £7,000 on safety improvements at the camp since the accident, including recruiting trained drivers to operate tractors.

Legal Outcome

The responsible County Scout Council admitted failing to undertake the management, administration, control and supervision of activities on the 385-acre site, and the charity was fined £5,000 and ordered to pay £7,000 costs.

What can we learn from what happened?

It can’t be argued that the scout leader wasn’t entitled to drive the tractor, and it is the case that the scouting movement does laudable work in training young people to be independent and self-reliant, but given the outcome it can be argued that she was not the right choice to drive the tractor as it seems the lack of adequate training contributed to the accident.

And while, at the time there had never been a serious accident or fatality, sadly this fatality was not the only one at the scout camp.  Please see the case study involving a drowning which is included in this month’s selection.

Source of Information

The Argus Newspaper

Times Educational Supplement

Share this Story

Facebook
Twitter
LinkedIn