An autistic man drowns in a reservoir

When a care worker employed to supervise a vulnerable man near open water is distracted by her phone

What happened? 

A twenty-nine year-old autistic man, who had the mental age of a four year old, was on an activity trip from a day centre, when he went for a walk around a reservoir, supervised by his care worker.  He walked about three quarters of the way around the path with the care worker, but unfortunately, at some point he fell out of her view and was subsequently found by two people, who were walking their dog, in the reservoir.

The man’s carer, a twenty-nine year old woman, had been ‘distracted’ while using her mobile phone rather than watching the man.  She spent more than nineteen minutes on the phone calling and texting contacts over a thirty-four minute period while she should have been supervising the man, and giving him her full attention while walking around the reservoir.

The fatality was jointly investigated by the Health and Safety Executive (HSE) and the Police.

Legal Outcome

The care worker pleaded guilty to breaching section 7(a) of the Health and Safety at Work Act 1974.  She was sentenced to four months imprisonment.

What can we learn from what happened?

The hazards associated with open water are well known and should not be under-estimated.  The likelihood of an accident occurring will increase when there are human risk factors, such as in this case when the man who died was particularly vulnerable, and so the need to provide effective supervision is essential.  This means not being distracted by a mobile phone.  The importance of not allowing lifeguards who supervise swimming pools to use or be distracted by their phones is well known and controlled.  Tragically, in this case this principle was not transferred.

Also, note the breach was of Section 7 of the Act, for failing to take reasonable care for other people.  This is fairly rare, but appropriate given that the carer was technically not an employer, although she was carrying out work-related duties.

Source of Information

SHP In-Court

Health and Safety Matters

Share this Story

Facebook
Twitter
LinkedIn