When what had never happened before, and was thought to not be possible, happened
What happened?
A father was travelling down a flume with his young son. It was a medium length flume, say 40m, had no serious or steep gradients, but you could still get up a bit of speed.
The rule was that children could travel with an adult, if sitting between their legs or on their lap. During the descent, the boy moved across on to the father’s side. The father was quite large, and was gaining speed. At one of the open sections of the flume, as it turned a bend, the centrifugal forces propelled the boy out of the flume and he dropped five metres on to poolside.
Amazingly, the boy bounced when he hit poolside and was unharmed.
The pool had been open for over 25 years, and this was the first time, as far as the staff were aware, that such an accident (or near miss in this case) had happened.
Legal Outcome
N/A
What can we learn from what happened?
This kind of incident had never happened before, but was it foreseeable, and if so was it reasonably foreseeable? Yes, if only because this is not the only time a flume-rider has been ejected from a flume. This is not to say that it can happen on ever flume in the UK, and it may be a very small minority where it could happen, but it still needs identifying as a genuine risk that needs to be managed.
What element of a flume ride is, for many, the most enjoyable? Getting up speed as you approach a bend on an open section and you push a load of water out of the flume which splashes the swimmers in the pool below? Great fun. Replace the water with a child, and it is less enjoyable.
In this case study, the boy had somehow moved laterally from centrally on his father’s lap to his side. The forces he generated when travelling round the bend would have been higher than normal, but not that unusual either. It all combined to cause what could have been a tragedy, but actually turned out OK – an incredible outcome.
The leisure centre subsequently tightened up its rule to require that adults only place children between their legs, not on their laps, so that the adult legs provide a barrier to any lateral movement.
The level of risk presented by flumes in this respect will vary greatly because all flume designs are different, so the best way to assess this level of risk is to really understand the dynamics of your flume and how its users, of all shapes and sizes, interact with it. This may mean members of staff trying out the flume a lot, so no great hardship there!
Source of Information
Reported to author on training course.