When a fault identified before Christmas isn’t dealt with before an accident on New Year’s Eve
What happened?
A 13 year-old boy was at a skate park at a large multi-sport facility operated by the city council on new year’s eve. He went to turn on floodlights unaware the electrical cabinet had been vandalised. He suffered an electric shock, resulting in the amputation of his left index finger, and required a skin graft on his middle finger.
An investigation by the HSE revealed that the door of the cabinet had been forced open and vandalised so that electrical parts at 240V were exposed.
A park ranger had identified that the cabinet was damaged just before Christmas, but no action was taken to repair it. There was a history of the cabinet being forced open and vandalism had occurred on three previous occasions.
Previous damage had been identified and repairs were made, but these didn’t address the problem. In addition, inspections of the sports area were made by park rangers and walkabouts were done by the staff from the sports village, but the cabinet wasn’t identified as something that needed to be checked.
Following the hearing, the HSE inspector said: “Anyone close to or touching the exposed live parts was in danger of serious injury from electric shock. The fact that the cabinet was located in a damp environment could also have made a shock more severe. It is disappointing that the health and safety management by the council didn’t address the risks that manifested. They failed to put in systems to control the risk, did not communicate the risks to employees and did not inspect the cabinet. Nor did they improve the mechanical protection of the cabinet or mark it as being an electrical danger.”
Legal Outcome
The city council pleaded guilty to breaching section 3(1) of the HSWA 1971 and was fined £5,000, with costs of £9,477.
What can we learn from what happened?
The hazard is the 240V electricity, and the potential harm it can cause is death. The risk factors that made it more likely that harm would be caused, and that harm could be severe was the access by children (ie could be vandalised or misused in some way), and the outdoor environment (ie damp conditions as identified by the HSE). The risks should have been managed though regular checks and remedial action and effective communication so everyone knew what they were dealing with.
The identification of the damage to the unit just before Christmas, followed by the accident on new year’s eve is also probably not a coincidence, although this is not flagged up in the SHP report.
Source of Information
SHP Online