Child fall through brittle skylight at school

When climbing up pipework to reach a fragile roof was too tempting

What happened? 

A school building roof was accessible by pipework on the exterior of the building.  A youth club was using the school premises at the time of the accident, a child attending the club climbed up the pipework on to the roof, and fell through a skylight .

A Health and Safety Executive report had previously indicated that the skylight on the roof was brittle.

The child (the claimant) argued that the council was liable under the Occupiers’ Liability Act 1984, as it was reasonable to assume that children might have been in the vicinity of such danger and the area could have been simply fenced off to prevent access.

Legal Outcome

The court found in favour of the claimant.

The court had to consider whether the council was at fault for not following the HSE report and doing very little to prevent the harm that was sustained to the child. This had to be balanced with the blame that would be assigned to the child for climbing on to the roof where he should not have been.

The state of the premises was inherently dangerous, particularly to a child. The school was negligent in not carrying out a risk assessment on the area, and not fencing the area off, as it would have been low cost to find a solution to the problem.

Importantly, it was held that if it had not been a child, the claim would not have been successful. The court held that the claimant was equally to blame and was therefore attributed 50% contributory negligence.

What can we learn from what happened?

Falling off flat roofs and falling through fragile roofs are a significant cause of serious accidents and fatalities, and falling through skylights crops up a lot.

In this case, the school will have clearly known that they had a flat roof with a skylight, which was accessible by the pipework.  They will have also known that they hosted (and possibly charged) a youth club.  It should come as no surprise that a child would be at least tempted to scale the pipework to the reach the roof.  So, as a minimum this risk should have been assessed, and it seems as though a simple, cost-effective solution was available (as is so often the case).

The HSE report heightens the need for effective controls even more, and it is normally a very good idea to act on HSE reports.

The court only awarded 50% of the damages, with the child being equally to blame, so he/she must have been of an age to understand potential risks.  But damages would not have awarded to an adult (although there will be exceptions to this if, for example, the adult is vulnerable in some way).  So often it is the risks associated with the behaviour of children that have to be prioritised.

Source of Information

NCRQ Level 6 Coursework

Law Teacher

Share this Story

Facebook
Twitter
LinkedIn