Claim that parents’ lack of supervision when hosting a bouncy castle party unsuccessful

When imposing a high level of duty on parents is not in the public interest

What happened? 

A child was having a 10th birthday party, and their parents hired a bouncy castle and a bungee jump.

Three children were playing on the bouncy castle.  One of the host parents was supervising the children on both the bouncy castle and bungee jump – she was attending to a child on the bungee jump and her back was turned when there was an accident on the bouncy castle.  One child hit another 11 year-old boy on the forehead with his heel while doing somersaults.  He suffered very serious head and skull injuries, leaving him in need of constant care.

The injured boy, through his mother, made a negligence claim against the parents, seeking compensation for the injuries suffered.

Legal Outcome

The judge in the High Court ruled in favour of the claimant.  The parents should have foreseen that the children were likely to behave in a boisterous manner, and therefore constant supervision was required.  If there had been constant, uninterrupted supervision, the accident would not, in the judge’s opinion, have occurred because the other child’s sudden somersaulting could have been stopped in time.  The judge used the terms ‘permanent look out’ and ‘continuous watch’.

The parents appealed.

The Court of Appeal overturned the decision.  It was not reasonably foreseeable that an accident causing injuries of this severity would occur.  It is not possible to preclude all risk that children playing together in this way might injure themselves or each other.  It was not in the public interest to impose this high a duty (to supervise constantly) on the parents.

What can we learn from what happened?

The Court of Appeal described this as a freak and tragic accident that occurred without fault.

Is it foreseeable that children will behave in a boisterous way on a bouncy castle?  Yes.  Is it foreseeable they will make contact with each other on a bouncy castle?  Yes.  Is it foreseeable that a child may strike another on the head on a bouncy castle?  Yes.  Is it foreseeable that such a head injury would lead to a child requiring constant care?  Well, yes, it happened.  But it would not be ‘reasonably foreseeable’, so there is no duty to prevent this outcome.  Could this have happened even with constant supervision?  Yes.

The appeal judge’s comment about imposing a high level of duty not being in the public interest is very welcome.  We don’t want parents being scared to do anything that just may lead to harm.

Source of Information

QLM Newsletter

Croner-i

Share this Story

Facebook
Twitter
LinkedIn