When being an agency worker is no different to being an employee when it comes to insurance
What happened?
An agency worker was using a double head mitre cutting saw to cut window frames when working as a window machine operative.
He was clearing debris from the machine when his hand got caught in the rotating blade, and his left index finger was severed. His middle finger also required reconstructive surgery, and he was unable to return to work owing to his injuries.
The HSE issued an Improvement Notice ordering the company to put a guard on the saw. It also requested that the firm produced documentation to prove it had Employer Liability Compulsory Insurance, but it later emerged that the company did not because it employed mainly agency staff.
Legal Outcome
The windows manufacturer pleaded guilty to breaching s2(1) of the HSWA 1974, and s1(1) of the Employers’ Liability (Compulsory Insurance) Act 1969, for not having insurance. It was fined £10,000 and ordered to pay £2500 towards costs.
An HSE inspector said: ‘Not having insurance in place was a gross failure of duty to their employees. It is crucial that all companies look at the relationship they have with its workers, agency or not, and the degree and extent of control they have over the work done, as this will indicate if insurance is required. Employers must look at the status of employees and determine if Employer Liability Compulsory Insurance is necessary.’
What can we learn from what happened?
It is not known whether the prosecution for the absence of guarding on the machine would have happened had it not been for the additional absence of employer liability insurance – the HSE may have thought that the Improvement Notice provided sufficient enforcement on their part. Either way, a pattern was emerging.
This case study is a reminder that, as the HSE Inspector said, employers must study their relationship with its workers as agency staff can fall under the employee umbrella.
Source of Information
SHP In-Court