When the effectiveness of the controls are massively outweighed by the risk presented
What happened?
A forty year old father-of-two was walking home after a day spent watching the FA Cup final between Arsenal and Chelsea. He had been drinking in various pubs. It was bank holiday weekend. He was dropped off near his home by a taxi soon after midnight.
A utilities company had been working near his home, digging a hole to locate a stop tap. The workmen had dug to about 5ft (1.5m) deep, the tap had not been found and they had been told to make the site safe. Soil was put back so the depth of the hole was 3.9ft (1.2m) deep and plastic barriers were erected.
It was decided not to place a footplate over the hole because the pavement had been closed and such a precaution would have posed a ‘trip hazard’. Two signs saying ‘Footway Closed’ were positioned either side of the hole, but they had fallen down.
The man fell into the excavation, and his body was found upside down at about 7.00am.
Legal Outcome
The HSE’s investigation found that the company should have identified the need for secure fencing, back filling or covering, as the excavation was to be left unattended for five days and there was no easy alternative route for nearby householders.
The utilities company were found guilty of breaching Section 3(1) of the Health and Safety at Work Act 1974. They were fined £100,000 and ordered to pay costs of £50,238.
An inquest had previously found the man’s death to be accidental, but concluded more could have been done to prevent it.
What can we learn from what happened?
As is often the case, here we have a series of events that together led to a tragedy. While 1.2m is not that deep, and we all will have seen trenches and excavations on the roadside far deeper, it was still deep enough for someone to fall in, and to consider the use of a footplate to protect this hole to be more of a hazard than the hole itself is baffling.
The safety barriers had fallen down (how many times do we see this?), and given the precautions were meant to last five days, then this control was clearly inadequate.
Then the unfortunate circumstance of the man who died, who had had a lot to drink and it is assumed this contributed to the fall and his inability to recover. It is no surprise that members of the public drink, get drunk and lose their bearings; in fact, society accepts it and often celebrates it. It is foreseeable that this will add to the risk, so must be factored in.
Lastly, for the record, such an accident would be classified as a fall from height. The Work at Height Regs apply when someone can fall from height, even from ground level or below.
Source of Information
SHP In-Court
BBC News Online