Five year-old boy breaks his arm falling down an exposed trench

When parents were expected to protect their children from the dangers presented by building sites

What happened? 

A building site located on a housing estate was in the process of being developed.  The developers had dug a deep trench for the purposes of sewage for the houses.

Two children passed across grassland which was part of the building site and a boy, aged five years, fell in and broke his leg. The children lived locally and were in the habit of using the grassland.  The developers had not taken any steps to prevent from happening, but technically the boys were trespassing.

There was a claim brought on behalf of the boy claiming for damages for the injury he sustained.

Legal Outcome

The legal issue, in this case, was whether the developer was liable for the injury caused to the injured child. It was particularly important to balance whether the children’s parents were to blame for the incident or whether the blame fell to the defendant corporation for not rectifying the trespass, or protecting against the damage to the children.

The court considered the trench to hold danger that children would not have foreseen, however, the developers were entitled to take into account that the children’s parents would not permit their children to play without protection in such an area.

On this basis, it was held that the developer was not under a duty to take steps to reduce the danger. The responsibility rested primarily on the parents.

What can we learn from what happened?

This is an historical case (1955), which is important because it is an illustration of how both the law has developed, and also how society’s view of where responsibility lies.  I really don’t think the developer would not be found to be liable these days.  There are a lot of examples of when children have found their way on to building sites because of an absence of effective security or protection, come across a hazard, suffered injury, and then the construction company has been successfully sued or prosecuted for breach of duty of care, even though the children will have been trespassing.  Children are attracted to building sites and they need to be protected from them.

So, this case is hopefully reassuring in that time and expectations have thankfully moved on.  That said, the relevance of parental responsibility has not gone away, just maybe shifted.  It is also sometimes the case that questionable parenting is the cause of a child’s accident, and there can be too much reliance on organisations, including sport and leisure facilities to carry out the role that parents really should.  It is a shared responsibility, and the trick is knowing, in law, where the line should be drawn.

Source of Information

NCRQ Level 6 Coursework

Law Teacher

Share this Story

Facebook
Twitter
LinkedIn