Girl falls from tree at outdoor activity centre

When the punishment is a reflection of what could have happened, not what did happen

What happened? 

At an outdoor activity centre, a group of children were climbing trees, wearing harnesses, and the activity was supervised by an instructor.  The instructor removed the girl’s harness after she descended a tree and was then distracted, leaving the girl unsupervised.  When the instructor was not directly supervising the girl she climbed a different tree – she forgot she was not wearing a harness, leant back as though she was wearing one, and fell eight to ten feet to the ground.

Legal Outcome

The activity centre was prosecuted and fined £250,000 for breaching the Health and Safety at Work Act 1974, for a failure to provide adequate risk assessments, an unsafe system of work, and inadequate monitoring.

What can we learn from what happened?

A very hefty fine, and reading this you may be assuming that the injury the girls sustained was very serious, if not fatal.  She actually ‘only’ broke her wrist – clearly very painful and great discomfort and inconvenience for a period of time after, but not life-threatening.

What could have been the outcome?  The failure to look after the girl could have led to a major head or spinal injury, or even a fatality – in determining culpability, this is what the court took into account.  This is why the fine was so high – it is about what could have happened not what did happen.

Also, the other factor in determining the level of fine is an organisation’s level of turnover, which would have been very high for this outdoor activity centre.

In criminal law, it is the exposure to risk that is judged, not the outcome (although clearly the latter can inform the former).  In civil law, however, when compensation is claimed, the process is focussed on the outcome.

Source of Information

SHP In-Court

Share this Story

Facebook
Twitter
LinkedIn