When the potential severity of the hazard was not matched by the quality of the checks and maintenance systems
What happened?
A cast iron hinged bollard on a cobbled pedestrianised street in a popular seaside town had previously been hit by a van. The bollard weighed approximately 69kg. As a consequence, the bollard was damaged, and the county council were aware of this.
A seven year old girl was climbing on the bollard when it toppled over and fell to the ground, taking the girl with it. As a result, she suffered serious, life-changing head injuries that were initially life-threatening and spent six months in hospital in a critical condition. The extent of her brain injury will not be fully known until her brain has matured.
An investigation by the Health and Safety Executive (HSE) found the bollard was damaged and not appropriately secured. This matter had been reported to Hampshire County Council prior to the incident and monthly scheduled inspections had failed to identify this. The damaged bollard had been secured with cable ties.
The HSE inspector said: ‘Council inspections failed to identify this risk over a long period of time and then, when alerted to the damage… failed to take the urgent action required.’
Legal Outcome
The County Council was found guilty after a trial of breaching Section 3(1) of Health and Safety at Work etc Act 1974 and has been fined £1.4m and ordered to pay full costs of £130,632.
What can we learn from what happened?
This is simply a case of identifying a hazard, and implementing a system of checks and maintenance that manages the risk presented. I have walked down the cobbled street where this accident occurred – it is a bit timeless and very popular with families, and it is hard to believe that such an accident could happen when it was so preventable.
A damaged cast iron bollard weighing 69kg is a significant hazard, in that it has the potential to cause harm. Being damaged and only secured by cable ties just emphasises why there was this potential. It should never have been left in such a state.
Source of Information
BBC News Online
SHP In Court