Lady has finger amputated when spotting for a friend using a Smith machine

When the signage warning of a ‘hidden’ risk is not adequate  

What happened? 

A lady was using a Smith machine at a gym operated by a well-known fitness club chain.  She was visiting the gym with a friend who provided help with the weights.

The machine is a large frame which roughly resembles a rectangular metal A-frame or trestle adjacent to the front of which are two vertical metal rails.  The bar is fixed within the rails which permit only a vertical movement, and cannot move from side to side, nor can it be raised or lowered on one side without an equivalent movement on the other.

At the base of each rail is a rubber block which acts to stop the barbell hitting the floor and in front of each rail is a series of hooks to allow the user to secure the bar at any point without the need to ask for assistance.

On the day in question, there was an additional ‘rubber or other solid block’ which was permanently fixed in place between the rail and the frame.  The position of this additional solid block was not known to the gym operator and it was not clear what its purpose was.

There were small signs informing users to keep their clothing, hair and body away from moving parts of the machine, but these signs did not have taken into account the additional rubber block.

This block effectively acted as a guillotine when the weights were moving.  The lady was standing next to the machine, leaning on it and unknowingly placed her hand by the rubber block.  As the weights were lowering, her finger was amputated.

She made a claim against the fitness operator.

Legal Outcome

The claim was successful.  Although there were two warning signs, neither was adequate as they weren’t easily visible, and they did not address the specific hazard presented by rubber block, the purpose of which was not made clear.

What can we learn from what happened?

The lady provided evidence to the effect that ‘had a member of staff approached her and asked her whether she knew how to use the machine, she would have said that she did and declined assistance’.  This did not, and could not, mean that she did not need advice or assistance about hidden risks…because they were hidden.

In many of the case studies in this library, claims have been unsuccessful when a judgement is made on the basis that a risk is obvious.  In this case it was not, so more should have been done to provide adequate information that can be easily accessed and understood.

While signage as a control measure certainly has its weaknesses, it can serve a valuable purpose, and the courts will recognise that.  But if the prominence and the priority given to the signage is not good enough, then it is not reasonable for members of the public to work out for themselves what risks they are exposed to.

Source of Information

VlexJustice

Share this Story

Facebook
Twitter
LinkedIn