Man blinded by faulty fitness equipment during PT session

When equipment bought on eBay by a PT was the cause of a ‘catastrophic injury’

What happened? 

The customer was sitting or kneeling on a stability ball and using resistance bands attached to a metal pole on an outdoor tennis court. The personal trainer had attached the bands to a metal ‘D ring’ with carabiner clips. The PT then instructed the man to pull the resistance bands to and away from himself.

The PT was using the equipment for the first time when the stitching gave way on the attachment and the resistance bands catapulted the ‘D-ring’ into his face. The PT was using his own resistance bands which he had bought on eBay.

The customer was left permanently blind in his left eye and his sight in his right eye is also affected.

Legal Outcome

The leisure operator pleaded guilty to breaching Section 3(1) of the Health and Safety at Work Act and Regulation 3(1) of the Management of Health and Safety at Work Regulations. It was fined £40,000 for each offence and ordered it to pay costs of £16,233.

The investigation found that the leisure operator had not carried out a proper risk assessment for using the resistance bands, and they accepted the equipment involved had not been checked.

The leisure operator also paid £1.3 million in compensation to the injured customer.

What can we learn from what happened?

Leisure operators will use an enormous variety of kit and they will need to assess the risks associated with their use to determine their procurement methods, what level of and what frequency of checking needs to be in place, what the level of competence is necessary to carry out those checks etc etc.  From a policy point of view, they will also need to determine whether, as in this case, individual employees can use personally owned equipment, and if so where can they buy it from (in this case eBay), and does it need to be authorised for use before put into action.

Lots of things to think about and decide on here, but that’s what safety management is all about.

The PT was employed by the leisure operator, and the leisure operator had a duty of care to keep its customers safe, so far as is reasonably practicable.  That is the bottom line.  In this case the equipment used was faulty, had not been checked, and the consequence was a ‘catastrophic injury’.

Source of Information

SHP In-Court

Share this Story

Facebook
Twitter
LinkedIn