Man breaks ankle climbing down steep stairs

When an injury caused by an employer is made worse by the employee

What happened? 

A man sustained an injury at work – he strained his back and hips and his leg was prone to giving way.

While in this state he attempted to climb down a steep concrete staircase without a handrail unaided. He got part way down and felt his leg give way so he jumped ten steps to the bottom. He suffered a fractured right ankle and was also left with a permanent disability.

Legal Outcome

The claimant’s action in attempting to climb the steps unaided knowing that his leg might give way was unreasonable. The defendant accepted liability for the injury sustained during his employment but disputed liability for the second injuries resulting from the claimant’s action in jumping down the stairs, and was successful in this regard.

What can we learn from what happened?

The claimant’s action amounted to a novus actus interveniens because his action in attempting to climb the steps unaided knowing that his leg might give way was unreasonable.  Novus actus interveniens is any intervening act that can sever the legal connection between a defendant’s actions and the harm suffered by the plaintiff – essentially while the initial injury was caused by the employer, the man took it upon himself to risk making the injury worse.

This is an historical case, albeit only 1969, but the legal principle would equally apply today.

Source of Information

E-Law Resources

Share this Story

Facebook
Twitter
LinkedIn