When a faulty ladder (any fault) should never be used at any height – that’s never
What happened?
A fifty-seven year old man was painting metal roof struts more than three metres high while carrying out refurbishment work.
The aluminium ladder he was using had been poorly maintained. A non-slip foot was missing and another was damaged, as was one of the rungs.
The ladder gave way, and the man hit the concrete floor below, dislocating his shoulder and shattering his knee. He spent ten days in hospital and had to have a knee replacement. When the accident was reported, he had been unable to work since as he still suffers discomfort and has mobility problems.
Legal Outcome
The employer was ordered to complete 180 hours community service after being found guilty of breaching regulation 7(2) of the Work at Height Regulations 2005 and regulation 5(1) of the Provision and Use of Work Equipment Regulations 1998.
After the hearing, the HSE inspector said: ‘The condition of the ladder was such that it should never have been used. Other more suitable equipment which was readily available on the site, such as a tower scaffold, but was not considered for this task. As a result, a man suffered major injuries that have had a significant impact on the rest of his life.’
What can we learn from what happened?
It is widely known that falls from height are the most common cause of fatality and serious injuries, and construction is where the highest number of these incidents happen. This is an example of why these facts never change from year to year.
The two main issues here are: Firstly the choice of equipment as stated by the HSE inspector, and secondly the maintenance of the ladder.
Regarding the maintenance, while this accident happened at 3m, the importance of maintaining and checking the condition of any ladder, regardless of what is going to be used for, cannot be over-estimated. You don’t need to fall 3m to hurt or kill yourself, and there are plenty of examples of serious harm being when falling from much lower heights. There is no way a ladder with missing and damaged feet and/or damaged rung should ever be used, for any job, ever.
Source of Information
SHP In-Court