Man loses sight in his only good eye when not protected by PPE

When the specific impact on an individual’s life also has an impact on the level of duty owed

What happened? 

A man sustained an injury in the war, leaving him with sight in only one eye.

When employed as a garage hand, a splinter of metal went into his sighted eye causing him to become completely blind.

The employer did not provide safety goggles to workers engaged in the type of work the claimant was undertaking. The employer argued there was no breach of duty as they did not provide goggles to workers with vision in both eyes and it was not standard practice to do so. There was therefore no obligation to provide the claimant with goggles.

Legal Outcome

The court found there was a breach of duty. The employer should have provided goggles to the claimant because the seriousness of harm to him would have been greater than that experienced by workers with sight in both eyes.

The duty was owed to the particular claimant not to a class of persons of reasonable workers.

What can we learn from what happened?

It would be interesting to know how his case would have panned out today if it were subject to criminal proceedings.  Almost certainly, in a criminal prosecution, the garage would have been found guilty for not providing PPE when there was a risk of a splinter of metal flying through the air.  This case, however, is not of today, it is very old (1951), and a criminal case would probably have found the garage to be not guilty.

The case in question is a civil law claim for compensation and I expect the outcome would apply in just the same way now as it did then.  It also demonstrates how the process for compensation is designed to redress, albeit in a clumsy way using money as the method, the impact on someone’s life.  For a man sighted in both eyes to lose sight in one would have a significant impact, but for a man sighted in one eye to lose that sight would be devastating.  This increases the duty on the employer to protect the employee from this eventuality, and explains the court’s decision.

Source of Information

NCRQ Level 6 Coursework

Share this Story

Facebook
Twitter
LinkedIn