When, if you are aware of a slippery surface, you don’t need to be warned about it
What happened?
A man was on a harbour wall operated by the council that, naturally, projects out into the sea, and from which the public could gain access to the prom. The wall sloped into the sea and at the time of the accident, it had algae growing on its surface.
The man stated at the trial that he had noticed the algae was slimy and wet and could foresee that this could be slippery. He did, indeed, slip on the algae, fell and suffered serious injuries as a result of the accident.
The man claimed to sue the council on the basis that there should have been an applicable signing, warning of the danger.
There had been no accidents in the long history of the harbour wall, and the council installed a warning sign following the man’s fall.
Legal Outcome
At the initial trial, the judge found in the man’s favour. The council appealed.
The appeal judge decided that a warning on a sign would not have informed the man of new information. The duty that was owed to the man, and the public, by the council under the Occupiers’ Liability Act 1957 was a duty to warn a visitor to the nature and extent of a risk if they were unaware. In this case, the man acknowledged that he was aware of the risk and stood on the algae nonetheless.
What can we learn from what happened?
This is an example of a case that is very specific to the circumstances and to the man who suffered the injury.
As far as the man was concerned, because he knew of the risks presented by the slippery algae, the presence of a sign would not have made any difference to the outcome. This is not to say that it wouldn’t have been the right thing to do have a sign to warn those who didn’t spot the algae. Indeed, the council installed a sign soon after the accident in question.
This is also another example of just how difficult it is know what level of warning or signage is necessary to let people know about things they could potentially work out for themselves. The Cobb juts out into the sea, and the formation of algae is as a minimum probably and as a maximum inevitable. The man recognised this, but what proportion of the normal population would reach this conclusion?…
Also, another example of an appeal overturning the original court decision.
Source of Information
NCRQ Level 6 Coursework
Law Teacher
E-Law Resources