When a club didn’t carry out reasonable checks regarding a potentially very dangerous event
What happened?
A cricket club was hosting a bonfire and conventional fireworks display.
The club had engaged a pyrotechnic company. They had dealt with two men from the company, who had performed for the club previously.
A third man said that he would be willing to help the company on a voluntary basis. He was dealing with a pair of mortars and as he placed the gunpowder charge into a mortar tube, the contents ignited exploding in his face and causing him severe burns and a broken arm.
The person from the club in charge of liaising with the company said that he was not aware that the volunteer (the claimant) was present on that night.
The judge accepted that the pyrotechnic display was potentially very dangerous, and the claimant had had no training or experience in the use of fireworks, and found that no one from the club had made a specific enquiry about insurance.
The judge noted that one of the men from the company was entirely unaware of the health and safety regulations covering the use of fireworks, and that the safety equipment for the claimant was inadequate.
There was no formal contract between the club and the company and that the club had no clear idea of what the company was intending to do. He concludes that the company was an amateurish organisation operating in a field which required the highest degree of professionalism.
Legal Outcome
The Judge concluded that the club and the company were liable. The club appealed, but this was dismissed.
The judge concluded that the club had failed to take care when selecting the pyrotechnic company – a person who engages an independent contractor to carry out work is not liable for the negligence of the independent contractor provided that the person exercised reasonable care in engaging a reasonably competent contractor.
What can we learn from what happened?
This case study is about fireworks, but could easily apply to any situation when a club or leisure centre or any organisation that hires out facilities engages an external contractor to provide a service.
The reason why you would engage an external contractor will normally be because they can do something you can’t – they are specialists. No cricket club is expected to know everything there is to know about fireworks, and the more specialised the service the less you are expected to know. But that doesn’t mean that there is no requirement to carry out reasonable checks. These will vary from service to service, but insurance would be a minimum, as well as knowing who will be providing the service, the nature of the hazards, and a general understanding of their competence.
Also, this issue is not just about non-sporty things like fireworks. A leisure centre with a swimming pool and a sports hall will really be expected to know about swimming, but probably less expectation of knowledge about, say, archery. Reasonable checks will be required.
Source of Information
NCRQ Level 6 Coursework