When not having a hinge guard is defendable, even when someone gets hurt
What happened?
A member of staff at a primary school was holding open an internal fire door to allow children to access the lobby to meet their parents, when a gust of wind caused the door to move, trapping her finger in the hinges. Her middle finger required partial amputation.
She made a claim under the Workplace (Health, Safety and Welfare) Regulations 1992 and the Management of Health and Safety at Work Regulations 1999. The claimant also alleged common law negligence. She sought damages of up to £10,000.
It was argued on behalf of the school that the door did not require finger guards as it was only to be used by staff, or by children under staff supervision. Further, it was argued there were no problems with the door before or after the accident, and that a finger guard was only fitted after the accident as an additional precautionary measure.
Finally, it was argued that the member of staff had been the author of her own misfortune, in failing to hold open the door using the handle on the outside, or by using a door wedge.
Legal Outcome
The judge made preliminary comments that he was struggling to see how the claim could succeed, as the claimant herself could not explain how the accident happened.
No evidence was required from the school as there was no case to answer. The judge held that even taking the claimant’s case at its strongest, he could not establish negligence against the school. He agreed it was just an unfortunate accident for which no one was to blame, and that the school had not breached its duty to the member of staff while at work.
What can we learn from what happened?
The hazards presented by doors closing and getting fingers trapped, the risk of this happening, and the controls put in place to mitigate the risk are always good topics to talk about – an everyday safety issue that is easy to deal with.
Hinge protectors are great – relatively cheap and very effective at stopping fingers from getting near to where they may get hurt. Does that mean every door should have them? Ideally yes, but in real life and in the eyes of the law, no. The school’s view was that this door did not require guards because it was only used by staff (adults) or by children under supervision. It is expected that adults will understand the risk, and won’t put their fingers in harm’s way. This teacher didn’t, and indeed, she was the author of her own misfortune.
It is also worth saying that the measures taken by the school to install a hinge guard after the accident did not compromise their case. This control just reduced the risk even further below what the law would find acceptable – the issue is always what was the level of risk in relation to legal acceptability at the time of the accident.
Source of Information
Zurich Insurance