When a tree (and a cracked branch) hadn’t been inspected for thirteen years
What happened?
A woman, who was thirty-six weeks pregnant, was carrying out the daily school run. She was driving along an A road with her thirteen year-old daughter and six year-old son when her car was struck by a large branch falling from a mature horse chestnut tree.
The branch broke through the windscreen and front driver window and struck the right side of the woman’s stomach. She was taken to hospital and her baby girl was delivered by an emergency caesarean, living for fifteen hours before sadly passing away.
The tree was under the control of the Borough Council.
An HSE investigation found that the large branch which fell had a crack on its upper edge where it was joined to the main trunk. It had begun to separate from the main trunk for at least one growing season before the failure. The tree had not been inspected for at least thirteen years.
Legal Outcome
The Borough Council pleaded guilty to breaching Section 3(1) of the Health and Safety at Work etc. Act 1974. They were fined £100,000 and ordered to pay costs of £49,363.
What can we learn from what happened?
Fatalities caused by falling trees have been, and will be, featured in this library, but this accident is notable for the impact being caused by just a branch. The tree was mature, so presumably significant in size, and it is shocking that it hadn’t been inspected for at least thirteen years.
Many organisations will have outdoor spaces under their control, and these will invariably include trees. They, therefore, have a duty to identify and manage the risks from falling trees and branches, and implement a robust system of inspection of trees within its remit.
The consequences of this accident were truly awful, and could have been prevented had these duties been carried out.
Source of Information
SHP In-Court