Patient handler suffers back injury but fails in bid to win compensation

When the saving of life or limb justifies taking considerable risk

What happened? 

A patient handler went with a colleague to collect a patient from a cottage, to take him to hospital. It was an urgent call requiring response within an hour.  The patient was a man in his early seventies, weighing between 12 and 14 stones. The cottage stairway was narrow, steep and had a bend in it. The patient handler and his colleague decided to take the patient downstairs in a carry chair. There was no other suitable piece of equipment available.

He carried the back of the chair and was walking forwards down the stairs, bearing most of the weight. As they descended, the patient handler’s colleague loosened his grip, leaving him to briefly bear the whole weight of the chair. He suffered jarring injuries to his thumb, back and knees.

There was no other way to do move the patient, short of removing an upstairs window and requesting the assistance of the Fire Service. This was a last resort that had only been done on three occasions that the Ambulance Service Senior Officer new of – it was a lengthy and difficult procedure and he doubted whether he would have called the Fire Service himself.

The patient handler made a claim against the Ambulance Service.

Legal Outcome

The Judge found for the patient handler, finding a breach of the Manual Handling Regulations (where manual handling cannot be avoided, the employer should take appropriate organisational measures using appropriate means to reduce the risk involved).

He found also that the patient handler should have been better trained to consider the alternative of calling the Fire and Rescue Service.

The Ambulance Service appealed.

The appeal judge considered the judge’s decision to be flawed, saying if the paramedic had been trained differently and encouraged to make use of the Fire Service when appropriate, there was nothing in this case that suggests that they would have been called. In fact, the option would have been rejected because it was not appropriate.

Regarding negligence, the starting point was that the Ambulance Service owed the same duty of care to employees, as did any other employer, whereas employees in services which are inherently dangerous, accept the risks inherent in their work.

Lord Denning in a previous case said the risk has to be balanced against the end to be achieved – ‘the saving of life or limb justifies taking considerable risk.’

In this case there was a balancing of serious injury which contained the risk of ending a career as against ‘considerable social utility’. The patient’s needs were urgent, and the Ambulance Service had limited resources.

The appeal was, therefore, allowed.

What can we learn from what happened?

This is a case which illustrates how duty of care can vary – it is not a constant, and it’s magnitude can change according to the context of the situation.  In this case the risks were worth taking because of the benefits provided to the patient.

Source of Information

NCRQ Level 6 Coursework

Share this Story

Facebook
Twitter
LinkedIn