Seventeen year-old paralysed when skiing off-piste on school trip

When a teacher’s decision to reprimand and not ban was the reasonable course of action 

What happened? 

Three school pupils (one seventeen years old) went on a school trip, which had been arranged for younger pupils.  The three older boys were intermediate skiers and had written consent from their parents to ski unsupervised.

Two of the boys were seen skiing off-piste, and while they were not skiing incompetently or behaving irresponsibly, this was not allowed so the teacher made sure the boys understood.  The boys, however, were seen by a teacher again doing the same thing. On this occasion the teacher reprimanded the pair severely and threatened to confiscate their ski passes.  The teacher did not carry out this threat as the boys assured him that they would not ski off-piste again.

The next day, the boys arrived at a narrow section of piste, and they were held up behind some slower skiers.  One of the boys chose to overtake, the second boy followed, but accidentally lost control, and skied off-piste.  He then fell down the slope and fractured his spine, causing permanent paralysis from the waist down.

The injured boy’s parents sued the school, claiming they were negligent because the second teacher should have confiscated their ski passes, or have arranged for them to ski under supervision (which would have reduced the level of supervision of the younger pupils).

Legal Outcome

The case was heard at the High Court, and the judgement made was that the school were 50% liable for the injury, saying that merely reprimanding the boy was not a reasonable decision for the teacher to have made.  The school appealed.

The appeal was heard at the Appeal Court, and it was held that the decision to give a severe reprimand and to accept their assurances not to ski off-piste again, was not, in the judges’ view, outside the range of reasonable responses in the circumstances.  The appeal was, therefore, allowed.

What can we learn from what happened?

This is quite a well-known case, and one that is often referred to when the issue of school trips or holidays are discussed in the context of risk management and the threat, perceived or otherwise, real or not, of schools being found to be negligent.  There has been, over the years, significant reservations expressed by schools who fear litigation, and significant concerns expressed by parents, pupils and society in general that the opportunities for schools to enable pupils to experience life outside the school grounds may be diminishing as a result.

This judgement, albeit at the second time of asking, will have allayed some of those fears.  If schools plan their trips properly and professionally, and if teachers made sound and professional decisions (such as in this case), then schools have nothing to fear.     

Source of Information

Guardian Online

Croners

Share this Story

Facebook
Twitter
LinkedIn