When the weight of the individual load is not excessive, but the cumulative effect of repetitive lifting had a significant health impact
What happened?
The Crown Court heard that the HSE received six (RIDDOR) reports of workers at a car components manufacturer who had injured their backs and been off work for more than seven days. Further investigations discovered that more workers suffered back problems but were not off work for seven days.
The HSE found that workers were expected to manually lift engine components weighing between 14 and 21kgs, hundreds of times per day during a shift. Mechanical lifting aids were either not provided, not suitable, or no training had been received by workers in how to operate them. There were no suitable or sufficient manual handling assessments in place.
Legal Outcome
The car components manufacturer admitted breaching Regulation 4(1)(b) of the Manual Handling Operations Regulations 1992. It was fined £183,340 and ordered to pay £21,277.10 costs.
What can we learn from what happened?
Manual Handling prosecutions are very rare. One reason for this is that it can be very difficult in a criminal case to make a strong enough link to be sure that the employees’ back conditions were caused directly by the working practices. We use our backs all the time, whether we are at work or not, and we can do damage to them at any time. In this case, however, the link was clearly very strong, and given the extremely high level of repetition, despite the relatively modest weight of the loads (although there may have been issues with distance travelled, abnormal shapes, lifting and putting down positions etc), for the employees to suffer from bad backs was inevitable.
Decent risk assessments would have identified the need for some mechanical lifting aids or any kind of equipment to help the employees with their work, and if there were such aids, it seems as though they were not offered the necessary training, information of instruction.
Source of Information
SHP In-Court