Swimming pool attendant falls through fragile roof into changing rooms

When the use of an unsafe space to store paperwork was not controlled because the school didn’t know the space was being used

What happened? 

A nineteen year-old swimming pool attendant and the pool manager were searching for paperwork in the loft above the pool changing rooms at a school.

She was walking across a roof beam when she lost her balance and stepped on to the fragile part of the roof, which gave way. She fell 2.5 metres to the tiled floor below, narrowly missing a tiled bench. She suffered a fractured wrist but nobody else was injured, as the changing room was empty.

The HSE Inspector found that the school had failed to carry out a risk assessment to identify the dangers of workers entering the loft, and to ensure that staff didn’t step on the fragile surfaces, saying ‘The outcome of this incident could have been very different. Falling from height, particularly on to such a hard surface, often results in severe injuries, or even death.’

‘In this case, the documents could have been stored somewhere easier to reach and if a simple risk assessment had been carried out, this would have been identified. I urge any organisation to consider where they store items, including paperwork, and how safe it is for an employee to access.’

The school told the court that it didn’t carry out a risk assessment as it was not aware that staff were using the loft as a storage area. It has subsequently put a lock on the loft hatch to prevent workers from being able to access it. The company has also removed all storage items from the loft.

Legal Outcome

The school pleaded guilty to breaching reg. 9(1) of the Work at Height Regulations 2005. It was fined £8000 and ordered to pay costs of £2276.

What can we learn from what happened?

This case study is included the library because it just sounds so familiar – both the practice of using a loft space to store paperwork, and the lack of awareness that the practice was taking place.

This is hopefully less of an issue now that so much more information is stored digitally, but it is not hard to imagine boxes and boxes just full of stuff that you dare not throw away and just has to go somewhere.

The dangers of fragile roofs always need to be emphasised as serious injuries and fatalities caused in this way form a significant proportion of all falls from height.  This makes sense – when you are, say, up a ladder or on a roof, you know you are at height so you will naturally take precautions.  But if you access a fragile surface, you may not be aware that it cannot take your weight.  In this case study, the pool attendant was relying on her balance to stay on the beams, so probably knew the gaps between the beams were fragile, but nevertheless these environments are just not good places to be or to store things.

Source of Information

SHP In-Court

Share this Story

Facebook
Twitter
LinkedIn