Teenage girl falls 7.5m when her younger belayer fails to control her fall

When allowing an 8 year-old to belay a 15 year-old novice climber = completely inadequate competence

What happened? 

A 15 year-old girl was using a climbing wall at an outdoor learning centre run by a county council.  It was her 5th climb, so very much a novice.

She was climbing on the indoor climbing wall whist being belayed by an eight year-old, who had only attended three previous climbing club sessions. On the day of the incident the eight year-old was using a certain belay device for the first time.

The climber lost her footing on the wall, but her younger belayer was unable to control her fall. She plummeted 7.5m onto the floor below.  She suffered bruised internal organs, as well as back and neck and other deep muscle tissue damage. She suffers on-going pain from her injuries, and continues to need physiotherapy.

An investigation by HSE found the climbers were being supervised by an instructor with a ‘completely inadequate level of competence.’

Specifically…

  • the instructor was not competent to run this type of progressive climbing club session, as she did not have the required climbing training and site-specific assessment;
    • the instructor allowed the belaying to take place without use of an additional back-up belayer and without direct supervision from the instructor;
    • there had been no use of a ground anchor or sand bag to counter the significant weight difference between the climber and belayer; and
    • there was no application of safety knots to prevent the climber from falling to the ground.

“In HSE’s opinion it was foreseeable that an accident of this type could occur. The resulting injury from such a 7.5m fall could have been much worse.”

Legal Outcome

The County Council was fined £10,000 and ordered to pay £2,599 in costs, and a victim surcharge of £120 for breaching section 3(1) of the Health and Safety at Work etc. Act 1974.

What can we learn from what happened?

Competence is at the heart of effective safety management, and while the law does not specify what competence is, there is often industry guidance that helps, and when it comes to sports when there is a risk of falling 7.5m, there is plenty of guidance to follow which will ensure safety laws are not breached and children, such as this 15 year-old girl, are not seriously and sadly hurt.

Source of Information

SHP Online

Share this Story

Facebook
Twitter
LinkedIn