When walking past unguarded lathes wasn’t enough to prompt any safety concerns
What happened?
This case study has already appeared in the library (August 2024), but focuses on a different failure that led to the fatality
The boy, an apprentice, was operating a CNC lathe used to cut steel components. He received no training and was not supervised. It was practice to clean the lathe with emery cloth while the lathe was still running, and this is what the boy was doing. The guards had been disabled to enable the operator to access the lathe.
The boy’s overalls, which were too big, became caught in the lathe. His arm was drawn in the machine pulling his face and head on to the lathe. He suffered massive facial and cranial injuries and died two hours later from cardiac arrest after being airlifted to hospital.
There were five lathes in the working area, none were guarded.
A training provider, as a work based learning sub-contractor, had a contract with the apprentice’s employer – they therefore received money for recruiting him and placing him with the employer.
The training provider was responsible for carrying out health and safety checks on the employer’s workplace and practices. Their learner handbook contained their health and safety policy and they confirmed that a health and safety review would be conducted before the apprenticeship started. It wasn’t. The tasks that apprentice would be doing at weren’t discussed with them, nor was the suitability of the workplace. They had stated on their pre-employment paperwork that ‘machinery was not to be used’ and claimed they had informed the employer of this.
Legal Outcome
There were a number of legal outcomes, and those focusing on the employer is featured in the previous case study.
The training provider never attended court and never entered a plea – they were tried for Corporate Manslaughter in their absence. They were prosecuted under HASAWA Section 3, were found guilty, and were fined £75,000 and ordered to pay £25,000 costs.
What can we learn from what happened?
This is a very good example of when an employer is not directly employing the accident victim, but had a material or significant influence over the outcome. The training provider had a legal responsibility to be competent, but they clearly weren’t. Their systems were not robust enough to ensure that adequate checks were carried out on the suitability of the workplace, and even though an NVQ assessor from the training provider did visit the workshop (and walked past the lathes to get to the employer’s office), it did not register that those very lathes were patently unsafe.
The law will always gravitate towards the employer, and the employers were suitably punished, but there are times when other organisations with a stake in safety will find themselves in the dock. The training provider in this case is now in liquidation.
Source of Information
DTD Training Presentations