When lightning strikes twice, and the second bolt is more powerful than the first
What happened?
A fifty one year-old man was working at a truck body shop. He was standing on a stepladder to spray-paint a lorry, when one of the feet on the ladder slipped down a grille in the concrete floor.
He fell two metres and suffered a multitude of injuries, which included a shattered left shoulder and collarbone, several broken ribs and a deep cut in his head. He is unable to work owing to his injuries and still suffers considerable pain in his shoulder.
The HSE investigated the incident and identified the company had failed to provide a safe working platform.
The HSE inspector also learned that the same worker suffered bruising a month earlier, when he fell off a stepladder while spray-painting a different vehicle. He reported the incident to his manager but it was not recorded in the company’s accident book, and no action was taken to ensure the work was carried out safely in the future.
Legal Outcome
The HSE issued a Prohibition Notice, which ordered it to stop spray-painting vehicles until a safe system of work was created. They also prosecuted the company for breaching reg.4(1) of the Work at Height Regulations 2005 (failure to organise and plan tasks).
The body shop was found guilty in its absence, was fined £7500 and ordered to pay £4923 in costs.
The company has gone into voluntary liquidation and hasn’t carried out any spray-painting since the incident.
What can we learn from what happened?
We can learn that lightning can strike twice, and the second bolt can be far more powerful than the first. The body shop had the opportunity to learn from the first fall, especially as it was reported, but despite virtually identical circumstances, it happened again with more serious consequences.
You could argue that the man himself should also have learnt, but as is normally the case, it is the employers who are first in line when it comes to apportioning legal liability.
Source of Information
SHP In-Court