Woman breaks her leg crossing a village green

When a small hole in the ground created two years before the accident leads to litigation

What happened? 

A picture-perfect village green was used by the Royal British Legion (RBL) to hold a village fete which included maypole dancing.  After the fete the hole left by the maypole was filled in.

At some point in the future, the item used to fill the hole was removed – when this happened or who removed it is not known.  About two years after the fete, a women walked across the village green, stepped into the hole, and fractured her leg.  She made a civil law claim for compensation against the owners of the village green and the RBL.

Legal Outcome

The claimant was initially successful in her claim.  The judge was satisfied that the hole was adequately filled in by the RBL, but still found them liable under The Occupier’s Liability Act 1957.

She appealed, and the Court of Appeal reversed the decision.

What can we learn from what happened?

There are quite a lot of interesting things going on here.

Firstly, and fairly obviously, this case demonstrates that the law can be used for this type of accident – a simple case of a member of the public walking across a public space and suffering a distressing injury.

Secondly, the law used was The Occupier’s Liability Act, so not strictly health and safety law, but still legislation that provides protection to the public when the owners or occupiers of premises, or in this case land, do not do what is considered reasonable to keep people they have invited safe.

Thirdly, the legal test was about ‘causation’ – who actually caused the accident, what was the link between someone’s actions or omissions and the accident itself.  The RBL had originally caused the hole in the ground, although they had filled that hole.  Linked to this is ‘remoteness’ – how direct was the cause and the harm.  While the RBL created the hole, the accident happened a full two years after the maypole was used – that’s a long time.

Fourthly, part of the judge’s consideration was that maypole dancing is a ‘desirable activity’.  There is community benefit to these types of events, and it would not be a good thing for society as a whole for the fear of this type of litigation to dissuade organisations from putting on these types of event.

And lastly, I hope this is a good example of when ‘health and safety’ did not go mad, and the court mad a very sensible decision, albeit only after appeal.

Source of Information

Casemine

Share this Story

Facebook
Twitter
LinkedIn