When the operator needs to protect the integrity of the (in this case ‘risky’) sport
What happened?
A woman suffered serious injuries in a skiing lesson on an indoor ski slope in Milton Keynes, operated by Snozone (Holdings) Ltd, when she skied into a pillar, and was off work for a year. She made a claim against the company.
Snozone said: “This was a simple skiing accident considering the inherent risks occurring in skiing, and that, in any event, the slope was well-maintained and kept safe such that it could not be in breach of its admitted duty of care.
The woman did not ski face on into the pillar due to loss of control. The evidence demonstrates that she did not lose control by virtue of a defect in the slope but rather it was an incidental fall unrelated to any defect – a common event in skiing.”
The judge found that immediately before the accident the appellant was distracted by an out-of-control snowboarder. The woman’s evidence was that the snowboarder caused her to wobble.
The judge needed to consider whether the ski slope was in breach of its duty of care, by looking at three aspects: (i) Inadequate risk assessment in relation to overcrowding and grooming; (ii) Overcrowding on the learner slope; and (iii) The absence of a 6pm groom on the night before the accident, in breach of established safety procedures.
Legal Outcome
In the 2021 court case, the judge held that (i) defects in the respondent’s risk assessment were not decisive in the context of this case; (ii) on the evidence before him, the learner slope had not been overcrowded; and (iii) the grooming regime could not have been responsible for the fall because the failure to carry out a 6pm groom was mitigated by a groom on the following morning.
The judge also found the distraction by the snowboarder to be a ‘significant factor in this accident.’ The judge also recognised that skiing is inherently risky.
The woman lost her case.
What can we learn from what happened?
I doubt anyone needs to learn that skiing is inherently risky, but the wider point is that many sports carry risks, and participation in them cannot really be exclusive of those risks. Operators of sports facilities, in this case an indoor ski slope, need to put in place controls to mitigate that risk, comply with whatever guidance is available, meet the needs of the law, all while protecting the integrity of the sport.
Source of Information
APIL Sports Injuries in the Courts Webinar delivered by KC Gordon Exall