When the assessment of risk needed to be very personal to the individual
What happened?
A 64 year-old women suffered from a form of dementia that led to an obsession with clothing and a need to wear excessive layers. She was a resident at a care home. She was alone in her room and had attempted to open the wardrobe door when she pulled it over on top of her, rendering her unable to breath. Due to her condition, the wardrobe in her room was locked to prevent her gaining access to the clothes inside.
She was found when the staff next checked on her. An ambulance was called but she was pronounced dead at the scene. She died as a result of compression asphyxia.
An HSE investigation established that the wardrobe had been attached to the wall before the women became a resident at the home. The screws used, however, did not penetrate into the blockwork of the building, so they were not adequate to prevent someone pulling it over.
The investigation concluded that the care home had failed to ensure the fixings used to attached the wardrobe to the wall were of a suitable standard. It also found that no information, instruction or training had been provided for the maintenance manager on how to carry out work on the wardrobe.
The HSE inspector said: “The company was aware of her obsession with clothing and that is why they locked her wardrobe. In doing so, it was eminently foreseeable that she would attempt to open it using force, and that the wardrobe therefore needed to be rigid and secure.”
Legal Outcome
The care home was fined a total of £85,000 and ordered to pay £48,000 in costs after pleading guilty to breaching section 3(1) of the HSWA 1974.
What can we learn from what happened?
While working in a care home is a specialised job which involves dealing with vulnerable people, and while in this case the condition was very specific to the individual, the principles can be transferred to a range of settings.
But regardless of the woman’s condition, anything substantial that can be fixed to the wall when it can be pulled on top of you, should and must be fixed to the wall, as, sadly, covered in other case studies in this library.
Source of Information
SHP Online