Woman slips when getting out of shower, and claims compensation

When you have a shower and things get wet and slippery, you need to be careful – who knew?

What happened? 

A woman was using a communal shower owned and maintained by the London School of Economics (LSE).  As she was exiting the shower her right foot slipped, causing her to fall and injure herself.  She made a claim under the Occupiers Liability Act 1957.

The woman alleged that a towelling bath mat should have been provided. Had it been, the incident would not have occurred. The university had a system of installing bath mats, and there was a dispute as to whether a mat was in place at the material time.

The woman described the shower room as a ‘trap’, because of the presence of water on the floor.  She also argued that grab handles should have been in place, given the relatively high step down from the shower tray to the floor.

The woman alleged that the university failed to carry out an adequate risk assessment of the shower room, and that the university failed to ensure that a safe and suitable floor surface was installed in the shower room.

Legal Outcome

The LSE drew the court’s attention to the concept of reasonableness.

Regarding the claims detailed above…

The court accepted the university’s evidence that a mat was available within the shower room, though the woman was not aware, as it had been hung up to dry by a previous user.

The court rejected the argument about the shower room being a ‘trap’, stating that water on the floor is inevitable within a shower room. The water was visible, and seen by the woman.

The court disagreed about the hand rails, holding that it was not a relatively high step down, and the shower tray was standard specification. A lip was required to retain water. To require handles would open the floodgates and impose these requirements in thousands of premises.

The court rejected the argument about the lack of adequate risk assessment, quoting: “I do not see what a formal assessment would have produced (if anything at all) beyond a statement of the obvious…”

The court stated that the floor was slip resistant. There had been no previous accidents of a similar nature, and the woman produced no evidence to support her arguments.

The claim failed.  The court found that the incident, heard in December 2016, was sheer bad luck.

What can we learn from what happened?

This case highlights the principle that not all accidents are the fault of another. Civil claims for compensation revolve around what is or isn’t ‘reasonable’.  If you have a shower then things get wet and slippery, and you need to be careful.  That said, there may be circumstances when it would be reasonable to provide additional facilities or design features to protect, for example, more vulnerable people.  This was not the case here.

Source of Information

Zurich Insider

Insurance Hound

Share this Story

Facebook
Twitter
LinkedIn