Zoo Keeper falls 2.5m off defective step ladder

When the step ladder being in a skip is not enough of a clue that it just might be defective

What happened? 

A female zoo keeper at a famous zoo was removing droppings from four aviaries using a step ladder, standing on the top of the step ladder, and was working at 2.5m above the ground.

The steps gave way and she fell.  She landed on a wooden floor, sustained neck pain, concussion and grazed her elbow. She attended hospital the next day for an x-ray which showed swelling of the soft tissue and she was also diagnosed with concussion.  The zoo keeper spent several weeks recovering from soft tissue damage to her neck.

The ladder she was using was defective.  It had been consigned to a skip but was returned to use because it wasn’t marked as such.

The charity, which runs the zoo, conducted an internal investigation and then informed the local council. The authority found that the woman, who had been working at the zoo for four years, had received no training to use the steps.

She had been due to have ladder training when she fell, but, according to the charity, was ‘at the bottom of the list’ as she did not usually work at height.

Legal Outcome

At the trial, the prosecutor said that the zoo keeper had not had any ladder training during her four years at the zoo, and the site’s risk assessment did not address the possibility of a worker falling from a ladder.

The judge agreed that the lack of training was a direct cause of the accident. The zoo admitted two health and safety breaches.

The zoo pointed out that any profit from the £50m annual turnover is used for its animal conservation work and urged the judge to limit the fine.  The fine was cut to £100,000 to reflect the charity’s status and then to £40,000 for other mitigating factors. He also imposed £8,000 costs.

What can we learn from what happened?

The zoo was evidently short of ladders, hence the defective step ladder being retrieved from the skip.  That the defective step ladder was not marked as being defective really should not have been a factor – just being in the skip was probably enough of a clue.

So, when a ladder or step ladder becomes defective, then it should be properly disposed of, as in destroyed or removed, because that will, at least, take away the temptation for it to be used.

Alternatively, make sure you have enough ladders in the first place.  The zoo had an annual turnover of £50 million, so a few hundred on such important safety equipment is not going to break the bank.

Source of Information

QLM Newsletter

IOSH Magazine

 

Share this Story

Facebook
Twitter
LinkedIn